Skills, Sustainability and Strong Futures for Culture
Tuesday 19 June, 2018
Herefordshire's first national culture conference, hosted by Herefordshire's a Great Place and supported by the Elmley Foundation, was held at The Left Bank in Hereford on 19 June, 2018. Almost 200 people who work across arts, heritage and culture came together to discuss skills, sustainability and how working together can help build a strong future for culture.
This digital download has been created by the Great Place team to share the Civic Fabric 2018 presentations, filmed keynote talks, and further resources that will help people working in the cultural sector dig deeper into themes discussed on the day.
PHOTOGRAPHS BY KIERAN WARBURTON | FILMS BY RURAL MEDIA
PHOTOGRAPHS BY KIERAN WARBURTON
FILMS BY RURAL MEDIA
Keynote addresses
Church Buildings and Communities
Maintaining a sense of place and serving the common good by Wendy Coombey MBE
Wendy has worked for the Diocese of Hereford for 17 years supporting parishes to develop projects that encourage closer working between church and community. Her work has an emphasis on improving the facilities within church buildings to encourage new activities and services based on community needs.
"Church Buildings, of all denominations, play a big part in the story of place and community in Herefordshire. They are the depositories of our stories, places full of our vernacular art, the workshops of our local skills and craftsmanship, places of culture and spirituality and a very real and visible presence in our landscape. However, how much longer can these buildings be sustainable in the face of so many challenges? What would be the impact on our local communities if we lost our church buildings – not just to our spiritual life, but our social and community life? Would it matter? This talk examines the threats and how they are being tackled at a local and national level, looking at how a range of organisations are testing new ways of working, developing new models of governance and exploring a range of new funding options. Responding to the Taylor Review as well as the current HLF Strategic Review and funding position, it looks in particular at Social Enterprise and the opportunities and challenges of adopting this approach in rural churches, and if we agree that change is necessary - how do we remove the barriers to that change and can it even be done?"
- Wendy Coombey MBE, Community, Partnership and Funding Officer, Diocese of Hereford
Useful links
- Diocese of Hereford: Crossing the Threshold toolkit, a step by step guide to running community projects
- Dementia Friendly Church Guide, produced by the Diocese of Hereford
- Business planning toolkit: Regeneration Taskforce, co-produced by the Churches Conservation Trust and Princes Regeneration Trust
- Historic England church regeneration case studies: St John's at Fernham and Keld Resource Centre
- Big Lottery Reaching Communities grant scheme, grants of over £10,000 to support organisations with great ideas that enable communities to thrive
- Diocese of Hereford's grant funding directory
- Church of England examples of funded regeneration projects
Community Ownership
Unlocking the power of community by Meena Bharadwa
Meena has over 18 years of experience working with communities and specialising in work around asset-based community development. Whilst working for Locality, Meena has led on work with Shropshire and Derby Councils on their Community Managed Libraries programmes; supporting local communities to develop partnerships and business plans to retain and develop their local libraries as sustainable community hubs.
"Across the country, communities are using important local buildings and spaces to transform the areas where they live. Community ownership creates genuine community control, strengthens the local economy, supports community-led regeneration and transforms local services. This is a chance to learn about community asset transfer and the opportunity it offers, the foundations to successfully run community buildings and hear about those communities who have been there and done it like the Hero Project in Coalville and Wem Town Hall in Shropshire."
- Meena Bharadwa, Development Manager, Locality
Useful links
- Locality: Understanding Community Asset Transfer
- Locality: Pillars of the Community, a guide to the transfer of heritage buildings
- To Have and to Hold, Locality's guide to long term community ownership and development of land and buildings
- Green Asset Guide for community organisations from The Environment Trust
- Community Asset Transfer legal structures: free online webinar published by My Community
- Case study: The Hero Project, Coalville
- Case study: Wem Town Hall, Shropshire
Strength in Collaboration
Local and national museum partnerships by Maria Bojanowska
In her current role as Head of National Programmes at the British Museum, Maria manages the museum’s national programme in close collaboration with a broad national partnership of over 200 museums and galleries. The national programme supports a portfolio of funded touring exhibitions and loans, as well as a responsive programme of sharing expertise and innovative vocational training for museum colleagues across the UK.
"The perspective and meaning that museums can bring to people's lives are now more essential than ever. In rural communities museums can act as a hub for a multiplicity of social activities and when these are delivered successfully museums can reflect, through events and programmes, the shared interests and concerns of the local people they serve.
"Museums are also adaptable, and in this current culture of cuts many have demonstrated innovation in working models and partnership structures. This presentation will explore the many ways in which museums have changed and how they are looking ahead, outwards and inwards, to identify the structures, people and skills required to allow them to manage change, become stronger, and ensure they are 'future proof'."
- Maria Bojanowska, Head of National Programmes, British Museum, London.
Useful links
- British Museum's National Programme
- Cumbria Museums consortium
- Ikon Gallery: www.ikon-gallery.org
- Museum-University partnerships initiative: MUPI
- Our Museum: Santa Cruz Museum of Art and Culture, case study of the effectiveness of participation
- Museums Association: Character Matters (2018 – 2020), a delivery plan co-produced by Produced by the UK Museums Workforce Steering Group
- Attitudes, behaviours and skills in the UK Museum Workforce: research commissioned by Arts Council England and Museums Galleries Scotland
- 'Future proofing' museums, a talk by Bridget McKenzie of Flow Associates
- Culture Change Toolkit from the Arts Council, with guidance on how to recruit and support diverse talent
- Kids in Museums Manifesto: 20 ways to make museums more family friendly
Civic Fabric Workshops
A range of people working in culture around the UK ran workshops at Civic Fabric 2018, with each session designed to look more closely at skills, sustainability and practical ways we can build strong futures for arts and heritage organisations.
Below are presentations from all six workshops, along with useful links compiled by workshop leaders and the Herefordshire's a Great Place team.
TRUST IN CULTURE: RESILIENT MODELS FOR THE HERITAGE SECTOR
This workshop took a closer look at different models of trust/partnership across the UK museum sector, including the transition to trust status, focusing on staff, training and skills required for new modes of operation.
The session was facilitated by Dr David Prince and Simon Pearce (Prince and Pearce Consultants), Janet Tall of Southwest Heritage Trust, Michael Spender of Wessex Museums Partnership, and Tony Butler of Derby Museums.
Click the buttons to download the individual presentations.
DOWNLOAD - DERBY MUSEUMS: MAKING THE MUSEUM WITH PEOPLE IN MIND
DOWNLOAD - WESSEX MUSEUMS PARTNERSHIP: THE BENEFITS OF PARTNERSHIP
DOWNLOAD - SOUTH WEST HERITAGE TRUST: BUILDING AN EFFECTIVE TEAM
DOWNLOAD - PRINCE AND PEARCE: TOWARDS A RESILIENT MUSEUM SERVICE FOR HEREFORDSHIRE
Useful links:
- South West Heritage Trust: www.swheritage.org.uk
- Wessex Museums: www.facebook.com/wessexmuseums
- Derby Museums: www.derbymuseums.org
- Prince and Pearce: www.princeandpearce.co.uk
SOCIAL IMPACT: WHT'S YOUR STORY?
This workshop, led by Meena Bharadwa, Development Manager at Locality, explored how organisations can empower local communities through carefully considering social impact.
The session asked attendees to consider what defines effective social impact as well as why it matters and to whom, from stakeholders to staff. It was also a chance to consider impacts in their local community and appropriate methods of evaluation.
Click the button to download the workshop presentation.
DOWNLOAD - SOCIAL IMPACT: WHAT'S YOUR STORY?
Useful links
- Locality tools: Community Engagement and Impact
- Social impact tools from Big Society Capital
- How to Evidence Your Social Impact, a guide from Social Investment Business
COMMUNITY CHURCHES: PATHWAYS TO PARTICIPATION
This workshop was an opportunity to hear from two community churches in Herefordshire that have adopted different governance models; changing the ways they relate to their local communities.
At Peterchurch in the Golden Valley, the Hub@St Peters has reshaped itself and redefined its purpose as a community hub, while St Michael and All Angels in Brampton Abbots is currently exploring new kinds of operating structure that will promote local enterprise, including an artisanal bakery.
The session was led by Wendy Coombey from the Diocese of Hereford, Sara Coleridge, Project Coordinator for The Hub@St Peters, Sam Hine, Project Manager for the Daily Bread and Director of Communities Can, and Jo Pilkington, Director of Brampton Abbotts Church Regeneration Group.
DOWNLOAD - THE HUB@ST PETERS: BECOMING A COMMUNITY HUB
DOWNLOAD - INTRODUCTION TO BRAMPTON ABBOTTS CHURCH REGENERATION
Useful links:
- The Hub @ St Peters: www.hubcommunity.org
- Brampton Abbotts Church Regeneration Group
- Crossing the Threshold toolkit from the Diocese of Hereford
- Craft Skills Toolkit and Business Planning Toolkit from the Churches Conservation Trust
- Dementia Friendly Church Guide, from the Diocese of Hereford
- WISH (Wellbeing Information and Signposting in Herefordshire): website for publicising community activity and church services
- Church funding advice is available from Simon Whaley, Church Projects and Funding Support Assistant at the Diocese of Hereford, at s.whaley@hereford.anglican.org
PEOPLE AND PASSION: RECRUITING, MANAGING AND VALUING VOLUNTEERS
This workshop was a chance to find out more about how to attract and support great volunteers across the cultural sector. There was a focus on offering great experiences; from increasing the capacity and confidence of hardworking teams, to offering further development opportunities - and insight about what happens when things go wrong.
The session was led by Ellie Jones and Ana Vaughan of the National Trust's Berrington Hall estate in Herefordshire.
DOWNLOAD - PEOPLE AND PASSION: RECRUITING, MANAGING AND VALUING VOLUNTEERS
Useful links:
- Ways to Volunteer: the National Trust's UK-wide introduction for volunteers
- NCVO Knowhow Nonprofit: an advice and support website with information on involving volunteers, strategy, recruiting and managing volunteers
- Volunteers and the Law: guidance on legal rights and obligations when managing volunteers
- The Building a Digital Workforce guide from NVCO
- Case study: Northampton Hope Centre - focus on a use of accreditation to reinvent their volunteering strategy
- Case study: The Children’s Society - focus on diversifying their volunteer workforce
DESIGN AND DELIVER: PRODUCING ACTIVITY PLANS FOR FUNDRAISING BIDS
This workshop offered practical advice, explaining how using the stories of your past to inform your future bids enables you to create a stronger and more successful Activity Plan for funders such as the Heritage Lottery Fund. It also looked at some best practice examples of Activity Plans. The session was led by Sarah Hollingdale of Hereford Cathedral.
DOWNLOAD - ACTIVITY PLANNING: ONCE UPON A TIME
Useful links:
- Heritage Lottery Fund's (HLF) essential guidance for anyone applying for Heritage Grants can be found in this Activity Plan Guidance
- The HLF message board, a online resource regularly updated with example activity plans
- 'Thinking about Heritage Activity Planning': detailed notes from Inspired North East's 2015 activity planning workshop
- Case study: Hereford Cathedral's Hackathon. This event formed part of the activity plan for the development of the eastern range of the cloisters, funded by the HLF
PURPOSE AND PARTNERSHIPS: CRAFTING SHARED VISION AND COLLABORATIVE FUTURES
In this hour-long session Maria Bojanowska, of the British Museum, and Tony Butler, of Derby Museums, talked about trusteeship and introduced the hallmarks of what makes a good partnership - from creating a level playing field at the start to having a clear understanding of each partners' purpose. Participants also talked about good examples of partnership, and how to encourage and support effective partnership working across cultural organisations.
Useful links:
- Clore Leadership report on Leadership and Organisational Resilience
- Governance: a practical guide, a Clore Leadership resource
- The Art of Partnering - this report from King's College London and the BBC explores the role partnership plays in enabling publicly funded cultural institutions to enhance the quality and diversity of their work across the UK
- The Future of University/Cultural Partnerships - from the 2016 Bristol Festival of Ideas, these short films ask what makes a successful partnership, and look at a case study involving Historic England and Hull City of Culture 2017
- More than the Sum of its Parts: looking a collaboration & sustainability in arts education, this online book offers examples of successful cultural partnerships from the US and outlines how these have benefited local communities
- Artswork's annual update on Cultural Education Partnerships in the South West reviewing cultural collaborations region by region
Feedback
We asked everyone who attended Civic Fabric 2018 what they wanted to get from the culture conference, and whether the event met their expectations. We also asked what we (Herefordshire's a Great Place project) could do more of, and what delegates wanted to talk about at future events.
Here's a sample of what this year's conference attendees said:
What are your objectives for the day?
- 'To hear about good practice, to hear inspiring stories about making heritage and culture more accessible to local communities, then take away and apply them.
- 'To support forward movement for creative cultural matters in Herefordshire leading to economic stability'
- 'To network and float ideas'
What other themes or topics would you like to discuss at future events?
- 'Resilience among volunteers'
- 'Making community initiatives survive after the departure of the original team'
- 'The role of parish and town councils in encouraging and supporting cultural initiatives'
What could the Herefordshire's Great Place project do more of?
- 'Provide more information on how freelancers can get involved'
- 'I’d love to see more to support young/junior professionals'
- 'This event was a great start, now let’s talk about class, gender balance, diversity, youth'
Civic Fabric 2018 was kindly supported by the Elmley Foundation.
It was the first in a series of Pride of Place conferences being supported by the Foundation and organised by Herefordshire's a Great Place.
In 2019, Great Place hosted Create/Fuel, a one-day event which put young creatives front and centre of a conversation about creative careers in rural places. Read about it here.
